The Western Horseman has the best steak in Amarillo. Period.

January 5, 2024 • General

Where City Chic Meets Western Grit at The Western Horseman Club

In the city of Amarillo, where the pulse of Texas beats the strongest, stands a beacon of culinary excellence and vibrant entertainment – The Western Horseman Club. An Amarillo steak house like no other, this establishment isn’t just making waves; it’s redefining the tide of dining and leisure in the Texas Panhandle. 

The team at the Western Horseman Club is on a mission to make their new establishment the best restaurant in Amarillo. So if you’re on a quest to find the best steak in Amarillo, your search ends at the illustrious doors of this revamped icon.

The Revival of a Legend – Now with The Best Steak in Town

Since 1983, the site where The Western Horseman Club now thrives was home to a beloved local bar. But as the saying goes, “Every sunset is an opportunity to reset,” and in 2021, when the original Western Horseman closed its doors, it set the stage for a remarkable sunrise. 

In the 80s, 90s and early 2000s, the Western Horseman was known as a dyed-in-the-wool honky-tonk roadside bar where you could grab a shot and beer, listen to a local live band and maybe work up enough courage to ask someone to help you work on your Texas two-step. The overall vibe of the place was “no frills.”

Fast forward to the present, and you have a revamped, revitalized, and rejuvenated establishment that’s nothing like its predecessor. This steakhouse in Amarillo, Texas, is a testament to tradition meeting innovation. The food, the bar, the stage and dance floor have all been modernized and refined into Amarillo’s hottest new steak house and live music venue featuring some of the Panhandle’s best and brightest live bands and musicians.

If you were someone who frequented the old Western Horseman, we encourage you to come back for a brand new experience like you’ve never had. If you’ve never been here before, you’re in for a real treat.

A Symphony of Flavors by Chef Rory Schepisi

At the heart of The Western Horseman Club’s transformation is Chef/Owner Rory Schepisi – a name that resonates with culinary excellence across Texas. Known as one of the finest chefs in the state, Rory’s expertise and passion are the secret ingredients that make this steakhouse in Amarillo a cut above the rest. 

As a top spokesperson for Certified Angus Beef ® and a luminary in the food world, her commitment to quality and flavor is unparalleled. Rory and her team are known for their love of beef in all of their establishments. They have a reputation for going toe-to-toe with the best steakhouses in Amarillo as they serve up some of the best steak in Amarillo as well as the mouthwatering burgers Amarillo craves! From the sizzle of a perfectly seared steak to the zest of her signature dishes, every meal at The Western Horseman Club is a celebration of finesse and flavor.

Not Just a Steakhouse, but a Lifestyle

Yes, we boast the best steak in Amarillo, but The Western Horseman Club is much more than a steakhouse; it’s a lifestyle. It’s where the steakhouse in Amarillo Texas meets the most sophisticated whisky bar in town. Housing over 135 different types of bourbon and scotch, including rarities like the 12-year Van Winkle Special Reserve, it’s a haven for connoisseurs and enthusiasts alike. 

And the experience doesn’t end there. With live music filling the air and a dance floor that invites you to strut your stuff, the club sets the stage for unforgettable nights. Whether it’s the free country dancing and line dancing lessons every Monday night or the live acts that grace our venue, there’s a rhythm and a beat for everyone at Amarillo’s premier steakhouse.

Although there is no obligatory Amarillo steak challenge here, we challenge you to find a better steak anywhere. However, if great music, amazing whiskies and the opportunity for a night of dancing aren’t your thing, we invite you to try some of our other options for the best steakhouse in Amarillo  

A Cut Above: Our Steaks Speak for Themselves

Diving into the heart of our menu, it’s clear why we’re touted as the new best steakhouse in Amarillo. Our Certified Angus Beef® brand steaks are a symphony of texture, taste, and tenderness. From the rich, flavorful New York Strip to the succulent, melt-in-your-mouth Filet Mignon, heralded as the best tenderloin in Amarillo TX, each cut is a testament to our commitment to quality. And for those with a penchant for the extraordinary, our hand-cut Ribeye is more than a meal; it’s a journey through the rich culinary heritage of Texas.

Our steaks are cooked perfectly to your preferred temperature and doneness, ensuring each bite is an experience in supreme satisfaction. Grilled over an open flame, the exterior of each steak is seared to a tantalizing crispness, locking in the natural juices and flavors that make our steaks unrivaled. 

Complement your meal with our handpicked selection of side dishes, from classic comfort foods to innovative creations, each designed to enhance your steakhouse experience. Some of our signature sides include: 

  • Sautéed Mushrooms and Onions
  • Macaroni & Cheese
  • Broccoli & Cheese
  • Green Beans
  • Loaded Baked Potato
  • Sweet Potato Fries
  • French Fries

At The Western Horseman Club, every plate is a canvas, and every steak is a masterpiece. Join us and discover why our steaks are not just meals, but celebrations of the finest culinary craftsmanship.

A Confluence of Culture and Comfort

Nestled within the embrace of The Westerner Extended Stay Hotel and Cactus Cove Inn & Suites, The Western Horseman Club stands as a beacon of culture and comfort. Recently renovated, these hotel properties offer a luxurious haven for both local and out-of-town travelers, perfectly complementing the exquisite dining experience at our steakhouse. It is also one more reason that our steakhouse is one of your best options for experiencing one of the most romantic restaurants in the city and should be at the top of your list of romantic things to do in Amarillo TX.

A Legacy of Excellence: Our Sister Restaurants

Our story of culinary excellence doesn’t end here. The Drunken Oyster and Sa•vór Tapas Bar, our sister restaurants, are jewels in Amarillo’s dining crown. Offering the best of Cajun and Spanish-inspired cuisine respectively, they embody the same ethos of quality and customer delight that The Western Horseman Club stands for.

All Articles


Get the latest from the Western Horseman on news and events.

Restaurants by FGH